Red Hat Responds to Recent Criticism Over Changes to RHEL Code Access

red-hat

Red Hat Enterprise Linux is a Linux distribution that targets its products primarily for businesses.

Shortly after the news about the restriction on access to Red Hat's code (news that we shared here) and after affected distributions such as Alma Linux and Rocky Linux made their position on the situation known, informing the community about the changes that will have to be made to their roadmaps.

Mike McGrath, Vice President of Fedora and CentOS Development at Red Hat, has announced the company's position on the recent events of ceasing to publish RHEL srpm packages in the git.centos.org repository and leaving the repository as the only public source of RHEL CentOS Stream package code, through a blog post.

red-hat
Related article:
From now on CentOS Stream will now be the only source for RHEL 

According to McGrath, Red Hat operates in accordance with the GPL license requirements , remains a proponent of open development processes, and continues to act in the best interests of the community by open-source its code and encouraging upward changes . The CentOS Stream project's Git repository contains the source code for all packages on which RHEL releases are based, and this repository is available to everyone without restriction.

They have called us wicked; I got a call from an IBM executive who was set up to turn Red Hat closed source, and that's just the "nice" stuff. So let's clear things up.

At the same time, the development of CentOS Stream is progressing at a certain pace , and the latest versions of the packages may not always match the RHEL packages, but all the code is in the repository and can be found if desired.

If changes are missing from CentOS Stream or discrepancies are observed, this should be treated as a bug that needs to be reported and corrected. However, Red Hat sees no value in rebuilding RHEL and is under no obligation to make things easier for distributions that perform rebuilds.

Despite what is said about Red Hat these days, we make our hard work easily accessible to non-customers. Red Hat uses and always will use an open source development model. When we find a bug or write a feature, we contribute our code upstream. This benefits everyone in the community, not just Red Hat and our customers.

We don't just take upstream packages and rebuild them. At Red Hat, thousands of people spend their time writing code to enable new features, fix bugs, integrate different packages, and then support that work for a long time—something our customers and partners need.

Red Hat's dissatisfaction stems from the fact that the company invests heavily in long-term package maintenance, new feature development, testing, and backporting of changes, while the creators of rebuilds resell other people's work without participating in it and without providing anything in return.

According to Red Hat, the distribution of products that are completely duplicates of other developments and created on the basis of a simple rebuild, without making their own changes, pose a threat to open source companies, as well as the entire open source ecosystem. , since they can bring open source software to a state that the bunch of hobbyists and hackers were in.

According to developers of alternative RHEL builds such as AlmaLinux and Rocky Linux, stopping the release of package code on git.centos.org will make it more difficult to prepare fully binary compatible RHEL builds that are identical in behavior (at the bug level). Since the CentOS Stream repository is out of sync with RHEL, packages may have some missing patches, some packages (for example, with the kernel) are released late, the version numbers of the packages in CentOS Stream, and RHEL don't always match.

Furthermore, the RHEL distribution is supported for 10 years, while CentOS Stream is updated for 5 years. Alternative builds of RHEL are presented as a system of checks and balances, offsetting Red Hat's business model, which imposes additional terms when supplying applications under the GPL and ignores the right granted by the GPL to unrestricted copies of the product.

Finally, if you are interested in learning more, you can find the details at the following link.

Alma Linux and Rocky Linux
Related article:
Due to RHEL restrictions AlmaLinux and Rocky Linux will rebuild their processes

Add as preferred source in Google